Things I learned · reflection
Why I Changed My Mind
I thought making solar panels follow the sun was automatically a better design. Then a few questions from experts made me realize how much we hadn’t considered.

What happened
During the 2022–2023 FIRST LEGO League season, my robotics team worked on an innovation project called Superpowered by the Sun. Our idea was to make solar panels follow the sun throughout the day instead of staying in one fixed position. If the panels could keep facing the sun, they could capture more sunlight and generate more electricity.
We started experimenting with LEGO models that used gears to rotate the panels. I thought the idea made a lot of sense.
Then we started talking to people who actually worked in renewable energy, including professionals at Vestas in Portland. They asked questions we hadn’t fully considered. How much would the design cost? What would happen when the moving parts wore out? Would the additional electricity generated be worth the cost of installing and maintaining the system?
Those questions made me realize we were so focused on making the panels move that we hadn’t spent enough time figuring out whether moving them was actually worth it.
One of the biggest turning points was when the experts pushed us to do a more detailed cost analysis. Before that, we’d focused mainly on the potential benefits. After the feedback, we realized that generating more electricity wasn’t the only factor that mattered. A design could work technically and still be impractical.
So we went back to research installation costs, solar trackers, and different mechanical approaches. We also explored a piston-based design instead of relying only on gears.
I had been treating an exciting idea like a proven solution. I hadn’t fully considered the trade-offs. Just because something can be built doesn’t necessarily mean it should be built that way.
What I think now
I used to think that if our design could generate more electricity, it was automatically better. A good solution has to balance performance with cost, practicality, and reliability.
I started looking at problems from more than one angle. Instead of asking only whether an idea could work, I think about cost, reliability, complexity, and whether people would actually benefit from it. I also became more comfortable changing an idea after someone challenged it.
An idea isn’t good just because it sounds clever or looks impressive. It becomes useful when you test your assumptions, understand the trade-offs, and figure out whether it actually solves the problem.
We never fully proved how much additional electricity our design would generate compared to a fixed solar panel. I also don’t know whether our specific design would have been cost-effective at a larger scale. Those are questions I’d want to answer through proper experiments rather than estimates.
When I’m working on a new idea, I try to ask myself what assumptions I’m making. I also want to hear from people who understand the problem better than I do, even when their feedback challenges something I’m excited about. Changing your mind isn’t the same as giving up. Sometimes it’s how you get closer to a better solution.
I used to think the hardest part of building something was coming up with a good idea. Now I think one of the hardest parts is being willing to change that idea when you discover something you didn’t know. And that’s a skill I’m still learning.
Related project: Solar-Panel Innovation: Superpowered by the Sun
